Will Palampur lose its tea gardens?...Hope not
What sets apart Palampur and its
neighbouring areas from rest of HP in terms of aesthetics and natural beauty?
The tea gardens, no doubt. It is these charming ‘ever-green’ bush-spreads over swathes of undulating landscape - that greet and soothe a sore eye as you
wander around - which make Palampur so special, so inviting. Enchanted by the
mesmerising view of the tea gardens with the snow-capped Dhauladhar in the
backdrop imparting it a divine touch, no tourist ever fails to stop by for a
photo shoot. For, the view is surreal, picture postcard perfect.
Therefore the news items ‘Govt
mulls policy to allow sale of land under tea’ and 'Changes in policy for sale of tea gardens...' in The Tribune dated 13 May and 19 May 2017 respectively (see photos), left me shocked and shaken. Will the tea gardens then go extinct,
like Dodo? Will this fabulous valley become a wasteland, an ugly sprawl of
concrete? A listless, grey, barren, noisy, traffic-choked, dirty, polluted township? Like, say, Shimla? An overpopulated, congested city bereft of the green of tea
gardens replaced by houses, shops, mansions, malls, multiplexes and what not,
with the essential civic amenities like water and power severely diminished,
causing power outages and water shortages for days on end…as in Shimla?
It is a frightening, scary
prospect, dear friends. Tea gardens have already been receding by and by, inch
by inch, meter by meter, acre by acre. Most of you must have been witness to vast
tracts of land in and around Palampur that were once a soothing carpet of
verdant green of tea gardens now having become a crowded conglomerate of houses and buldings rearing their ugly heads everywhere. Worse, with the enforcement agencies
looking the other way, encroachments by the new home-wallas along the link roads
have turned them into a traffic hazard. Much worse is yet to come.
I personally maintain that the
tea gardens are a precious, inviolable ‘heritage feature’ of Palampur and of Kangra valley. Agreed, the tea-planters
have custodial rights over them. But then haven’t they gotten away with not coming
under the land ceiling act, 1972, unlike the other, general kind of landowners who had
to part away with sizeable chunks of their lands that went to the tillers? No
such axe fell on the tea-planters. But
this huge concession had a specific rider: the tea-planters would be the ‘custodians’
and not the ‘owners’ of tea gardens. They will neither sell, nor change the
character of the land under these gardens for any reason whatsoever. However, gradually,
slowly, on one pretext or the other, the tea gardens kept on being sold/used.
And now to make matters terribly
worse, the present HP government near the end of its current term, as the news
goes, is mulling an amendment to facilitate sale of tea gardens and thus wipe
them out once for all. This implies that they would in due course become a thing of the past. I
think it would be the most brazen assault on the valley's ecology by the present
government: to deprive the residents of this beautiful, priceless asset of
Palampur and divesting it of its unique green cover in one fell sweep. With the
tea gardens, the trees that are a part of a ‘teagarden ecosystem’ will go too. We
built our homes keeping in mind the natural endowments, ecology and environs as
an inseparable, integral part of Palampur. Therefore to deprive us of these
natural features wholesale is just not right: morally and ethically at least.
Even otherwise it is stab in the back of those who came under the Land ceiling
act and the tea planters were not. One can't have the cake and eat it too, after all. Let the governmentt look at it in the right
perspective and not succumb to the pressure/lobby. Let the tea-planters’ issues and
problems be addressed, and let there be a robust policy by the government to
save the tea gardens from the impending doom. Let Palampur stay beautiful and green.
| Will posterity see the tea gardens only in pictures and albums? |
| Will tea gardens become a thing of the past? (This photo is courtesy, Dr RG Sud) |
*
When Jagrata went underway at Sughar
On Saturday (13 May) last, as
Sughar prepared to retire for the night’s sleep, a Jagrata got underway. The
loudspeakers came live and high-pitched cacophony of the event began hitting us
with all the thunder and fury. The venue being barely about 500 meters away
from our house, we found the ‘bhaints’ and ‘bhajans’ (mostly cheap adaptations
of romantic filmi tunes!), the chants and the slogans, the harmonium and the
dholak beats, too ear-splitting to bear. We tried to brazen it out anyway hoping that
it wouldn’t go beyond 10 or at the most 10.30 PM. But there was no let up. Then
we shifted our bed and migrated to one of the rooms at the back, the doors and
windows tightly shut. But still being at full blast, there was no respite from the noise and we ended up tossing, turning and shuffling in the beds waiting for the
loudspeakers to stop. Now it was past 12 AM and no relief seemed in sight.
Exasperated, I picked up my phone and dialled 100, not expecting any responsethough. However,
happily, a half-sleepy but polite and helpful voice said: “Ji, namaskar. Police
control room.” The policewalla took note of the problem and the location and assured
help. Relieved, I went into a ‘waiting mode’ hoping for the end to the
unrelenting noise-assault. An hour went by. I had to call 100 again. “Nothing
has happened?” the same voice asked. “Ok, hold on.” Then I could hear the
fellow talk to his colleague discussing the matter. A minute later, he told me
that a police party has already left and would be there any time. He also gave
me the name and number of the Head constable, one Mr Satish. I rang up Satish.
He said that they have located the venue and are almost there. When I went out
to our upper veranda, I could see the police vehicle with flashing blue and red
lights. In a few minutes the loudspeakers had fallen silent.
The Jagrata then went on its course but at a low pitch and so we finally were able to have our quota of sleep, not without feeling very
thankful to our police for being friendly, responsive and helpful.
In passing may I ask: Is
organising night-long Jagratas the right way to propitiate our gods and
goddesses? That too with jarring tunes based on cheap filmi songs? And at roof-shattering
sound levels? Have the sweet soulful melodies of Meera, Tulsi, Sur Das, Rahim vanished
from our consciousness? Lastly, isn’t, shouldn’t, religion be a personal and
private affair rather than a noisy extravaganza to disturb the entire
neighbourhood? For me it is nothing but trivialization of our grand and glorious religion.
*
Quotes of the week
Would have dealt with pain of her death had she been shot. I would have taken her body in embrace one last time
- Mother of the 23-year-old who was subjected to savage gangrape and murdered near Rohtak (The Tribune)
Social media (is) helpig Indian classical music
- Ustad Amjad Ali Khan (DH)
Nudity is beautiful, don't make it sexual
- Paris Jackson (DH)
*
Random headlines
12-year-old girl dies as father denies money for her treatment (DH)
India ageing gradually; every 5th person to be 60+ by 2050 (DH)
About 40 per cent of food in US gets wasted: study (DH)
Human ancestors stayed in trees longer than thought (DH)
New "winged" snake species discovered in US (DH)
***

About your post regarding the tea gardens. Let me be very blunt. Mr Sharma your pious hopes will be belied. In a decade or two the tea gardens will become part of folk lore. The old timers will start thus "once upon a time there were beautiful tea gardens in the Palam valley...". Majority of tea gardens are owned by a few families who are politically very well connected. They always manage to get their way. The present day 'lame-duck' government seem to be bowing down to their pressure.
ReplyDeleteI couldn't agree more with you Dr Sushant. Who cares for "pious hopes" and laments of lesser mortals like me? I have, anyway, emailed my post to the NGT and the HP High Court. It may be a vain hope but let's keep trying in whatever little ways we can. The scenario of Palam valley denuded of tea gardens looks too frightening, too unbearable.
DeleteThanks very much for sharing your thoughts with me, put so nicely.
My dear Sharmaji, apropos your brilliant post on the likely onslaught on the tea gardens of our town beautiful.The narrative is awe-inspiring and inviting for comments.In this context, I would like to quote a recent statement of an acclaimed US environmentalist," I have been thinking up-till now that environmental degradation is owing to loss of biodiversity and natural ecosystems imbalance but I was mistaken. It is due to self-aggrandizement and insatiable greed which is incurable".
ReplyDeleteYou have raised anther burning issue which had been agitating my mind;Jagratas emanating night long jarring notes depriving the students from their studies and divesting the sick and old from much needed rest.This obnoxious behavior plagues not only Palampur but country at large.Temporal limits have been fixed but nobody adheres to them.
I loved reading your insightful comment dear RP. The quote aptly highlights the malady of our present times: mindless greed and to get rich quick and fast at any cost. It would indeed be a sad day to see Palampur shorn of its beauty: the tea gardens. Maybe something happens to reverse this march towards destruction.
ReplyDeleteYour concern about the mindless noise through loudspeakers all in the name of God and worship is as it should be. You know I have been conveyed a note of resentment by the organisers of the Sughar jagrata for calling the police. Galat kaam ke liye shikayat karna bhi gunah hai aaj kal!
Anyway, thanks very much once again!
Two very different but very concerning issues. The HP Govt should be looking at ways to improve our Tea productivity, flavour, output, advertisement etc. by bringing in more scientific & technical methods into it, instead of mulling over such stupid ideas. The Virbhadhra Govt looks assured that they are not coming into power any time soon again so make hay while the sun shines? Our state runs pretty much on tourism to which no more tea gardens will surely be a setback.
ReplyDeleteLate night jagratas are everywhere in India. I feel that the organizers of such events feel that if they are doing this to please the gods, no one should come in their way. A bit of arrogance comes with it. Even if they go beyond what is allowed and required. Why late night loud parties are frowned upon then? That maybe someone else's way of pleasing some God's too!
But its good to know that Palampur has locals like you who not only write about such issues to raise awareness but take action (whatever possible) to inform/request authorities to take action before it's too late!
Salute to you and your indomitable spirit!