Naseeruddin Shah’s book has been on my reading table this Feb week
And makes me write about my (PU) days when I was callow, dumb and meek
Naseeruddin Shah's memoir and my musings on PU Chandigarh
I am reading Bollywood actor Naseeruddin Shah’s memoir ‘And Then One Day’ these
days. It is an engrossing, charming book written with luminous honesty that
Naseeruddin is known for. Among several interesting things, he writes about the
AMU, Aligarh. And he paints a dim, unflattering picture in regard to its
insularity, and general air of neglect and apathy in some respects. Reading
that, I am reminded of my own days at the no less prestigious PU Chandigarh in
the good old seventies, and find some resonance with him.
After
having missed entry in Medical College Shimla by a whisker – for which I had no
real regrets – I got admission in the PU’s zoology department. Looking at the
beautiful, sprawling campus with neatly arrayed, grey, red-tiled buildings,
lawns, water fountains, playgrounds, I was overwhelmed with joy. This is the
place where my talents will blossom…where my worthy professors will ignite
the spark of scientific quest and empower me with knowledge and learning…make
me a scholar, an academic worthy of respect and admiration…What pure joy it
would be to hear brilliant, thought-provoking lectures from them, and
participate in steamy, stimulating discussions, debates and discourses to delve
deeper into the mysteries, puzzles and wonders of biology... Thus would the
cobwebs of my ignorance be removed from my poor rusty mind…Thus would the
sunshine of scientific temper light up the dark recesses of my inner self and broaden
my mental horizons to take on and embrace
the whole world. With such fantasies flooding my mind, for a few days I walked
the hallowed corridors of PU’s science departments with a sense of pride and
exultation.
But my
dream was short-lived.
As the
classes commenced and we settled into a regular routine, my fantasy-world began
to crumble; optimism began giving way to mounting disappointment with each
passing day, week, month and year.
There
we were: a batch of 30-some huddled in a classroom with boys and girls perched in
distinctly separate clusters. Soon a grave, ponderous professor would enter
with an old musty file tucked under his arm. He/She (mostly he) would open the
file and on cue, in hushed silence, we would open our notebooks and pens and
get (battle)-ready. Then there would follow a marathon, non-stop, 1-hour
dictation from out of the mouldy, yellowing, dog-eared pages stashed in the
file. Sometimes our aching, tired fingers failed to catch up with the
professor’s dull but fast paced drone. But who would dare ask him/ her to repeat the
missed word or line? At times some words or sentences remained inaudible or
improperly heard. But it didn’t matter…we had to march on doughtily, regardless.
This went on class after class, teacher after teacher.
Classes
over, we would tuck our note-books away in some corner of a shelf in our hostel rooms.
These were meant to be opened only at the time of house exams, and the final
annuals in peak summer. Come exam days and sweating and fretting we sat long hours late into
the nights in our fan-less rooms, mugging up a few select topics out of the many
scribbled in our notebooks. It was sheer gamble, but if lucky, we found questions relating to the stuff
learnt by rote in the question paper and belched it out feverishly on answer-sheet
after answer-sheet.
That
was how we were taught, trained, nourished and groomed as future zoologists at
PU Chandigarh!
In the
evenings, to get away from the day’s dull, uninspiring rigmarole, some of us
wandered off either to the theatres to watch Bollywood movies ('Rekhas' and 'Hema Malinis!) or to the sector
17 shopping complex to ogle at (only furtively and from a safe distance) buxom Sikhnis strolling about
leisurely there, mostly accompanied by handsome brawny Sikh hunks.
Another exciting diversion for some of us was to meander off to the arts blocks
bubbling with life and energy with sprightly, vivacious ‘arts girls’ to ogle and salivate
at - unlike the ponderous, introverted, reticent, glued-to-the-microscopes,
romanceless girls of our science departments.
Naseeruddin
Shah had at least the cigarette-smoking, 'feisty' lady-professor Zahida Zaidi in
the English department at the AMU to recognize his latent talents and show him
the way. Later he had an erudite teacher Ebrahim Alkazi (may his tribe
increase) at the National School of Drama (NSD) to take him under his wing to
inspire and guide him through. But sadly, I had none at any stage of my formative, learning years.
But having
said that, it would be very dishonest and unfair of me to lay the entire blame
for my poor innings at PU on the teachers alone. Some of the blame must rest on
me too for having been casual and careless about my classes with Epicurean
tendencies having a greater sway over me than commitment to studies.
Be that
as it may, when I came home with the degree under my arm, I had no clue at all
where to go. And it was with great effort that I had to de- and re-learn
zoology entirely on my own to pass muster as a teacher in a college later on,
with a secret vow NEVER to replicate the follies of vain worthies who (mis-) taught me at the
university.
Perhaps I bored you with my personal
outpouring above. Well, coming back to Naseeruddin’s book, if you like this
genre of writing, which I personally find the most inspirational reading of
all, I strongly recommend this gem of a memoir.
***




Wonderful!your PU experience paid off in converting you a very good teacher of Zoology; at least student's feedback was more than satisfactory
ReplyDeleteThanks very much Dr Kanwar. Yes, I did try my level best to offer something better than what I recieved from my teachers.
DeleteThanks for your appreciation.
Dear Dr. Subhash
ReplyDeleteIm simply in love with your piece of writing which is something worth reading and I look forward to it.The way you go on exploring things and accurately paint them and make the readers transport themselves to the situation and or make them feel connected is really remarkable! You have a beautiful mind n soul.I wish I, could write like you someday.
Best Regards
Shipra Saklani
Dear Shipra,
DeleteI am delighted to know that you find my pen-pushing interesting and worthwhile. I don't know if I deserve all this praise but still it is all music to my ears! And I thank you very much for this. I think since I try to be honest and true and write what I feel in the depths of my heart, that's what finds resonance with my dear and discerning readers like you.
I assure you that you will write far too better than me in the years ahead. Just keep reading and writing regularly, every single day perhaps, if you really want to hone your skills and excel as a writer. My best wishes are with you.
My love and regards to you too.
Thanks a lot for your kind and motivating words. I will truly follow ur advice.
DeleteRegards
Thanks. Just have full faith in your abilities and forge your way ahead whatever be the odds.
DeleteGood luck!
Universities,are a highest seat of learning and dissemination of knowledge the world over. India has contributed in no less measure by by the do
ReplyDeleteUniversities are a seat of highest learning and dissemination of knowledge the world over.India have contributed in no small measure to the world science through brain drain which continues unabated since sixties to this day despite all archaic teaching methodology. That none of our universities figure anywhere in the 500 top ranking institutions of the developed world is also a stark reality.This applies to our IITs and IIMs in equal measure.
ReplyDeleteYou are absolutely right. India was once a torch bearer to the world.This land cradled top class scientists, poets, writers, philosophers, astronomers who contributed so much to world knowledge. But, as you so aptly say, our universities and other top institutes have failed to come up to the global standards. Corruption, political interference, erosion of autonomy, lack of vision...there are so many ills that have crept up in the system.
DeleteAnd it should be a matter of worry and concern for all.
Thanks a lot for sharing your thoughts.